Social Europe

politics, economy and employment & labour

  • Themes
    • Global cities
    • Strategic autonomy
    • War in Ukraine
    • European digital sphere
    • Recovery and resilience
  • Publications
    • Books
    • Dossiers
    • Occasional Papers
    • Research Essays
    • Brexit Paper Series
  • Podcast
  • Videos
  • Newsletter
  • Membership

Germany’s reliance on its healthcare ‘brown angels’

Lys Kulamadayil 5th January 2022

The recruitment of nurses to meet shortages in the global north has side-effects—not all good—on their countries of origin.

Kerala,nurses,Germany
Unlike most of their professional peers, these Kerala nurses were able to find work at a clinic in Kerala (EstrellaBuena/shutterstock.com)

There’s a line in Mira Nair’s film Monsoon Wedding: ‘Computer engineers are India’s biggest export!’ Maybe it should say nurses instead.

To address the severe shortage of nursing staff in Germany, in December the federal employment agency, die Bundesagentur für Arbeit (BA), signed an agreement with the state of Kerala on their recruitment. The agreement, based on the 2020 Skilled Immigration Act, is the second of its kind Germany has signed with a partner beyond the European Union.

It will be implemented through the Triple Win programme run by the BAand the organisation for development co-operation, die Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ). This programme already manages the recruitment of healthcare personnel from Bosnia-Herzegovina, the Philippines and Tunisia, as well as student nurses from Vietnam. It is so-called because it promises German healthcare providers a steady supply of well-trained personnel, the individuals recruited an exciting professional and personal future, and their home-state governments alleviation of some of the pressure on their domestic labour market.

‘Mild demeanour’

The groundwork for this recent BA-Kerala agreement was laid in the 1960s. At the time, German and local clergy partnered to recruit young women from Christian communities in the state to be trained as nurses in Germany. According to the documentary Brown Angels, telling the story of these women, they were thought to be particularly well suited for this role, due to their ‘mild demeanour’ and ‘Christian values’. Such programmes, mostly run by the Catholic Church, continued for two decades.


Become part of our Community of Thought Leaders


Get fresh perspectives delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for our newsletter to receive thought-provoking opinion articles and expert analysis on the most pressing political, economic and social issues of our time. Join our community of engaged readers and be a part of the conversation.

Sign up here

Whereas scarcity of health personnel was a problem for healthcare providers around the world, Kerala soon began to mass-produce them. So, not before long, the ‘brown angels’ were staffing hospitals in Australia, the United States, the United Kingdom, Austria, Switzerland and the gulf states—and, more recently, Italy, Belgium and Ireland.

Yet India too suffers from a shortage of health personnel. The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends a minimum of four nurses and midwives per 1,000 people but it estimates that in 2019 India had little over half that—3.26 million in a population of 1.38 billion. Worse, a recent study estimates that only 1.4 million are employed in their profession in India and suggests that the country has just 0.6 adequately qualified nurses and midwives per 1,000 people.

The international recruitment of Indian nurses is subject to the WHO Global Code of Practice on the International Recruitment of Health Personnel, adopted in 2010 by its World Health Assembly. This non-binding code provides ‘ethical principles applicable to the international recruitment of health personnel in a manner that strengthens the health systems of developing countries, countries with economies in transition and small island states’. It includes, among other things, the duty to ‘discourage active recruitment of health personnel from developing countries facing critical shortages of health workers’.

Germany has pledged to abide by the code but it claims that the BA-Kerala agreement is not in violation of that pledge. The federal government’s defence is that the agreement is limited to Kerala, which accounts for only 3.1 per cent of the population of India. Yet, according to the WHO, the state also accounts for 38.4 per cent of India’s nurses.

Massive scale

As a result of the 1960s recruitment programmes, Kerala has been training nurses on a massive scale, with the objective for them to emigrate. They have become a significant source of foreign income and eventually part of the state’s development model.

Diaspora nurses reliably send back remittances, which contributed 3.1 per cent to India’s gross domestic product in 2020. This is by far the highest share among the ‘BRICS’ countries (including Brazil, Russia, China and South Africa). And, in proportion to population, the highest share of remittances goes to Kerala.

This foreign cash-flow comes at a cost: it has inflated land prices, while giving rise to some fairly complicated identity politics. But the highest price is paid by those who do not succeed in securing a position abroad.

Rather than taking pressure off the domestic labour market, more than half a century of international recruitment has created a market—for nursing colleges. These graduate tens of thousands of nurses every year who have no professional perspective in their home state.


Support Progressive Ideas: Become a Social Europe Member!


Support independent publishing and progressive ideas by becoming a Social Europe member for less than 5 Euro per month. You can help us create more high-quality articles, podcasts and videos that challenge conventional thinking and foster a more informed and democratic society. Join us in our mission - your support makes all the difference!

Become a Social Europe Member

Predatory practices

In India, nursing is a four-year degree course—and a costly one at that. The total cost averages somewhere between 600,000 and 800,000 rupees (€7,000-9,300). In practice, the cost of this fairly competitive degree cannot be recuperated by exercising one’s profession domestically.

In 2017, the government of Kerala fixed the minimum wage for nurses at 20,000 rupees a month, yet locally employed nurses report monthly salaries as low as 6,000 rupees. They also testify to predatory practices—including terminating the employment of pregnant staff or pressurising them to have an abortion.

The salaries and conditions are such that the vast majority of qualified nurses from Kerala elect not to pursue their profession in their home state, let alone migrate to another in India to do so. They take a different career path or, if their families can afford it, simply stay out of the labour market.

Some end up in Europe, but in precarious 24/7 domestic-care positions or with copious debt owed to a recruitment agency. Some are forced to emigrate to a country, such as one of the gulf states, where nurses might be paid better but whose poor human-rights records look even poorer if one focuses on the rights of migrant workers.

Risky business

Against this backdrop, the BA-Kerala agreement is at one level obviously a good thing. It not only centralises and formalises the recruitment, which has in the past been carried out informally—making it prone to fraud—but implementation will be in partnership with Norka Roots, the government agency in the state capital, Thiruvananthapuram, which liaises specifically with non-resident Keralites. This will hopefully cut out private middlemen and so protect recruited nurses from extortionate brokerage fees.

Yet the agreement revivifies the problematic Kerala development model, based on remittances, providing yet another incentive for young women to bet their fortunes on the risky business of nursing. It’s an investment which, even with this agreement, is bound to fail more often than it will pay off.

Very few Germans today leave school with the intention of becoming a nurse for the rest of their lives. Those who do tend to retire early or withdraw for extended periods, due to the physical and mental toll of the profession.

Given the challenging and, in some instances, hazardous working conditions, the job does not pay well and salaries vary significantly among states and between public and private providers. And, according to the union of healthcare workers, Bochumer Bund—only founded in May 2020—despite being a profession dominated by women the gender pay gap in nursing averages €200-300 a month.

As a result, it is estimated Germany will need an additional 150,000 care workers by 2025. To meet this demand, international recruitment will be an indispensable component. At the same time, labour migration does not fix the profession’s problems. Health workers deserve more respect and validation, which begins with improving their working conditions and addressing ethnic and gender inequalities.

Lys Kulamadayil
Lys Kulamadayil

Lys Kulamadayil is an SNSF postdoctoral researcher at the Amsterdam Centre for International Law and a visiting fellow at the Global Governance Centre at the Graduate Institute Geneva.

You are here: Home / Society / Germany’s reliance on its healthcare ‘brown angels’

Most Popular Posts

Russia,information war Russia is winning the information warAiste Merfeldaite
Nanterre,police Nanterre and the suburbs: the lid comes offJoseph Downing
Russia,nuclear Russia’s dangerous nuclear consensusAna Palacio
Belarus,Lithuania A tale of two countries: Belarus and LithuaniaThorvaldur Gylfason and Eduard Hochreiter
retirement,Finland,ageing,pension,reform Late retirement: possible for many, not for allKati Kuitto

Most Recent Posts

Russia,journalists,Ukraine,target Ukraine: journalists in Russia’s sightsKelly Bjorkland and Simon Smith
European Union,enlargement,Balkans EU enlargement—back to the futureEmilija Tudzarovska
European Health Data Space,EHDS,Big Tech Fostering public research or boosting Big Tech?Philip Freeman and Jan Willem Goudriaan
migrant workers,non-EU Non-EU migrant workers—the ties that bindLilana Keith
ECB,European Central Bank,deposit facility How the ECB’s ‘deposit facility’ subsidises banksDavid Hollanders

Other Social Europe Publications

strategic autonomy Strategic autonomy
Bildschirmfoto 2023 05 08 um 21.36.25 scaled 1 RE No. 13: Failed Market Approaches to Long-Term Care
front cover Towards a social-democratic century?
Cover e1655225066994 National recovery and resilience plans
Untitled design The transatlantic relationship

ETUI advertisement

The future of remote work

The 12 chapters collected in this volume provide a multidisciplinary perspective on the impact and the future trajectories of remote work, from the nexus between the location from where work is performed and how it is performed to how remote locations may affect the way work is managed and organised, as well as the applicability of existing legislation. Additional questions concern remote work’s environmental and social impact and the rapidly changing nature of the relationship between work and life.


AVAILABLE HERE

Eurofound advertisement

Eurofound Talks: housing

In this episode of the Eurofound Talks podcast, Mary McCaughey speaks with Eurofound’s senior research manager, Hans Dubois, about the issues that feed into housing insecurity in Europe and the actions that need to be taken to address them. Together, they analyse findings from Eurofound’s recent Unaffordable and inadequate housing in Europe report, which presents data from Eurofound’s Living, working and COVID-19 e-survey, European Union Statistics on Income and Living Conditions and input from the Network of Eurofound Correspondents on various indicators of housing security and living conditions.


LISTEN HERE

Foundation for European Progressive Studies Advertisement

The summer issue of the Progressive Post magazine by FEPS is out!

The Special Coverage of this new edition is dedicated to the importance of biodiversity, not only as a good in itself but also for the very existence of humankind. We need a paradigm change in the mostly utilitarian relation humans have with nature.

In this issue, we also look at the hazards of unregulated artificial intelligence, explore the shortcomings of the EU's approach to migration and asylum management, and analyse the social downside of the EU's current ethnically-focused Roma policy.


DOWNLOAD HERE

Hans Böckler Stiftung Advertisement

WSI European Collective Bargaining Report 2022 / 2023

With real wages falling by 4 per cent in 2022, workers in the European Union suffered an unprecedented loss in purchasing power. The reason for this was the rapid increase in consumer prices, behind which nominal wage growth fell significantly. Meanwhile, inflation is no longer driven by energy import prices, but by domestic factors. The increased profit margins of companies are a major reason for persistent inflation. In this difficult environment, trade unions are faced with the challenge of securing real wages—and companies have the responsibility of making their contribution to returning to the path of political stability by reducing excess profits.


DOWNLOAD HERE

About Social Europe

Our Mission

Article Submission

Membership

Advertisements

Legal Disclosure

Privacy Policy

Copyright

Social Europe ISSN 2628-7641

Social Europe Archives

Search Social Europe

Themes Archive

Politics Archive

Economy Archive

Society Archive

Ecology Archive

Follow us

RSS Feed

Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter

Follow us on LinkedIn

Follow us on YouTube