Social Europe

politics, economy and employment & labour

  • Themes
    • Strategic autonomy
    • War in Ukraine
    • European digital sphere
    • Recovery and resilience
  • Publications
    • Books
    • Dossiers
    • Occasional Papers
    • Research Essays
    • Brexit Paper Series
  • Podcast
  • Videos
  • Newsletter

Social-ecological public procurement

Susanne Wixforth and Christian Berger 15th December 2022

The vast sums disbursed in procurement and subsidies by public institutions must lever good work amid the green transition.

subsidies,public procurement,criteria,social,ecological,unions
The Mall of Berlin—behind the swish setting lay a story of underpayment of Romanian workers by subcontractors engaged for the construction (Stephan Schlachter / shutterstock.com)

Awarding public contracts or subsidies by not only price but also according to criteria of social and ecological sustainability should be a central policy lever for fair design of the transition to a carbon-neutral economy. This would mean, for example, ensuring construction projects bar exploitative treatment of migrant workers or disbursing monies on social considerations when expanding renewable-energy sources.

Two striking examples of what can happen when public supervision is inadequate show why. One is the ‘mall of shame’ in Germany—a luxury-shopping and housing complex, the Mall of Berlin, which opened in 2014. For the construction of this large-scale project, hundreds of workers from Romania were employed by subcontractors on an hourly wage of €6.

Legal action was eventually required to extract the wages due, this being far short of the collectively stipulated hourly wage for construction. Yet these were not recovered in full. The German labour court ruled that only the subcontractors were liable for how the workers were treated and paid—not the general contractor—and they filed for bankruptcy.

All this happened at the gates of the Berlin House of Representatives. The ceremonial opening was attended by the then mayor. Public authorities, in particular the Finanzkontrolle Schwarzarbeit (Financial Control of Illicit Work), did not adequately inspect the site. Failure to pay wages, the use of bogus-self-employed construction workers and abuse of subcontractor chains were treated as if petty misdemeanours.


Our job is keeping you informed!


Subscribe to our free newsletter and stay up to date with the latest Social Europe content. We will never send you spam and you can unsubscribe anytime.

Sign up here

Similar picture

The ‘Henry on the train’ case in Austria, which made it all the way to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), paints a similar picture. On the Austrian Federal Railways (ÖBB) route from Budapest to Munich, staff were provided by a Hungarian subcontractor (Henry am Zug).

Austrian law stipulates that such a posting of employees across national borders must be notified in advance. Yet neither was the posting notified nor did the company pay its employees for the passage through Austria, in accordance with the Austrian collective agreement. Rather, they received the significantly lower Hungarian wage, thereby undermining the central principle of the EU Posting of Workers Directive, ‘equal pay for equal work in the same place’.

The CJEU however assumed, in its ruling in 2019, that the service would start (for instance, sorting goods) and finish (settling accounts, for example) in Hungary. A sufficient connection to Austria was consequently denied. The ÖBB—a public contracting authority—terminated its co-operation with ‘Henry on the train’ because of how this all looked. According to the court, however, the subcontractor’s conduct was lawful.

From these exemplary cases, a clear demand emerges: no public contracts or subsidies, direct or indirect, should be granted without social- and labour-law conditionality. Compliance with minimum wages or the locally applicable collective agreement, as well as the creation of good work, must apply throughout Europe.

Great demand

Another Austrian instance shows how such conditionality can be postively provided by the legislator. The Renewables Expansion Act of 2021 incentivises generation of renewable electricity from hydropower, wind power, photovoltaics, solid biomass and biogas through investment grants and market premia. There is great demand for these subsidies: when the fourth call for proposals was issued in October, more than 23,600 prospective recipients applied within five minutes.

In addition to general eligibility requirements for the market-premium procedure, special eco-social objectives were stiupulated to provide for higher standards of protection for employees and improved regional value creation. The Austrian Trade Union Confederation (ÖGB) has developed the following proposals on social criteria which should be incorporated into the award procedure, to check the suitability of subsidy recipients:

  • compliance with remuneration and social-security provisions and no convictions under relevant labour legislation;
  • application of relevant collective agreements and compliance with corresponding labour- and social-law standards;
  • existence of a works council (if a company consistently employs at least five employees) or proof of support for the establishment of such;
  • employment of individuals disadvantaged in the labour market (50-plus, long-term unemployed, youth and so on);
  • increasing and promoting length of employment;
  • a responsible human-resources strategy (including on training and retraining);
  • quality-assured apprenticeships and fulfillment of apprenticeship quotas;
  • gender-equality and anti-discrimination measures, and
  • promoting Austrian/European value creation in purchases (of components, for example).

If state subsidies are to be awarded, conditionalities stemming from labour and social law must be stipulated. At the same time, subsidy recipients should not be limited to a few large companies but should include small and medium enterprises. Therefore, the ÖGB proposes that the criteria listed are to be understood as a pool from which at least three must be met.

Regulation depends crucially on control. Without, at the very least, random checks and consistent sanctioning of violations of subsidy conditions, such conditionalities would otherwise remain nothing more than paper tigers.


We need your support


Social Europe is an independent publisher and we believe in freely available content. For this model to be sustainable, however, we depend on the solidarity of our readers. Become a Social Europe member for less than 5 Euro per month and help us produce more articles, podcasts and videos. Thank you very much for your support!

Become a Social Europe Member

Setting an example

The state must set an example as a contracting authority and provider of subsidies. The implementation of procurement projects, especially in cross-border situations, is still characterised by wage and social dumping. Unfair competition by undercutting wages, social-security contributions and general labour standards undermines cohesion in the EU.

European public-procurement law, as well as that on state aids, must counteract this. The disbursement of taxpayers’ money must routinely be tied to social and ecological conditions. EU procurement directives already allow that contracts need not be awarded solely by the most favourable price. But it remains at member states’ discretion to decide whether a contract is awarded to the cheapest bidder or to that which takes social, labour and environmental aspects most advantageously into account. This must become mandatory.

According to the European Commission, across the EU about €1.9 trillion—around 19 per cent of European gross domestic product—is spent annually on procurement by public authorities. So the private sector must also be more closely monitored.

Conditions such as those involved in the construction of the Mall of Berlin are unacceptable. The number of personnel in national inspection authorities must be increased. The credibility of the European Labour Authority is also at stake, if it does not take an active role in combating wage and social dumping and develop appropriate social-ecological guidelines for procurement by EU institutions.

The development of a European social-security ‘passport’ to allow real-time verification of mobile workers’ social security in their posting country has long been on the trade unions’ list of demands to combat illicit work. Especially in times of crises, workers in the single market must be protected against exploitation.

Susanne Wixforth
Susanne Wixforth

Susanne Wixforth is deputy head of the Economic Policy Department in the Vienna Chamber of Labour.

Christian Berger
Christian Berger

Christian Berger works in the Economic Policy Department of the Vienna Chamber of Labour, with a focus on industrial policy and structural change. He is also a university lecturer, among others at the Vienna University of Economics and Business and the Medical University of Vienna.

You are here: Home / Economy / Social-ecological public procurement

Most Popular Posts

Visentini,ITUC,Qatar,Fight Impunity,50,000 Visentini, ‘Fight Impunity’, the ITUC and QatarFrank Hoffer
Russian soldiers' mothers,war,Ukraine The Ukraine war and Russian soldiers’ mothersJennifer Mathers and Natasha Danilova
IGU,documents,International Gas Union,lobby,lobbying,sustainable finance taxonomy,green gas,EU,COP ‘Gaslighting’ Europe on fossil fuelsFaye Holder
Schengen,Fortress Europe,Romania,Bulgaria Romania and Bulgaria stuck in EU’s second tierMagdalena Ulceluse
income inequality,inequality,Gini,1 per cent,elephant chart,elephant Global income inequality: time to revise the elephantBranko Milanovic

Most Recent Posts

transition,deindustrialisation,degradation,environment Europe’s industry and the ecological transitionCharlotte Bez and Lorenzo Feltrin
central and eastern Europe,unions,recognition Social dialogue in central and eastern EuropeMartin Myant
women soldiers,Ukraine Ukraine war: attitudes changing to women soldiersJennifer Mathers and Anna Kvit
military secrets,World Trade Organization,WTO,NATO,intellectual-property rights Military secrets and the World Trade OrganizationUgo Pagano
energy transition,Europe,wind and solar Europe’s energy transition starts to speed upDave Jones

Other Social Europe Publications

front cover scaled Towards a social-democratic century?
Cover e1655225066994 National recovery and resilience plans
Untitled design The transatlantic relationship
Women Corona e1631700896969 500 Women and the coronavirus crisis
sere12 1 RE No. 12: Why No Economic Democracy in Sweden?

Foundation for European Progressive Studies Advertisement

Discover the new FEPS Progressive Yearbook and what 2023 has in store for us!

The Progressive Yearbook focuses on transversal European issues that have left a mark on 2022, delivering insightful future-oriented analysis for the new year. It counts on renowned authors' contributions, including academics, politicians and analysts. This fourth edition is published in a time of war and, therefore, it mostly looks at the conflict itself, the actors involved and the implications for Europe.


DOWNLOAD HERE

Hans Böckler Stiftung Advertisement

The macroeconomic effects of re-applying the EU fiscal rules

Against the background of the European Commission's reform plans for the Stability and Growth Pact (SGP), this policy brief uses the macroeconometric multi-country model NiGEM to simulate the macroeconomic implications of the most relevant reform options from 2024 onwards. Next to a return to the existing and unreformed rules, the most prominent options include an expenditure rule linked to a debt anchor.

Our results for the euro area and its four biggest economies—France, Italy, Germany and Spain—indicate that returning to the rules of the SGP would lead to severe cuts in public spending, particularly if the SGP rules were interpreted as in the past. A more flexible interpretation would only somewhat ease the fiscal-adjustment burden. An expenditure rule along the lines of the European Fiscal Board would, however, not necessarily alleviate that burden in and of itself.

Our simulations show great care must be taken to specify the expenditure rule, such that fiscal consolidation is achieved in a growth-friendly way. Raising the debt ceiling to 90 per cent of gross domestic product and applying less demanding fiscal adjustments, as proposed by the IMK, would go a long way.


DOWNLOAD HERE

ILO advertisement

Global Wage Report 2022-23: The impact of inflation and COVID-19 on wages and purchasing power

The International Labour Organization's Global Wage Report is a key reference on wages and wage inequality for the academic community and policy-makers around the world.

This eighth edition of the report, The Impact of inflation and COVID-19 on wages and purchasing power, examines the evolution of real wages, giving a unique picture of wage trends globally and by region. The report includes evidence on how wages have evolved through the COVID-19 crisis as well as how the current inflationary context is biting into real wage growth in most regions of the world. The report shows that for the first time in the 21st century real wage growth has fallen to negative values while, at the same time, the gap between real productivity growth and real wage growth continues to widen.

The report analysis the evolution of the real total wage bill from 2019 to 2022 to show how its different components—employment, nominal wages and inflation—have changed during the COVID-19 crisis and, more recently, during the cost-of-living crisis. The decomposition of the total wage bill, and its evolution, is shown for all wage employees and distinguishes between women and men. The report also looks at changes in wage inequality and the gender pay gap to reveal how COVID-19 may have contributed to increasing income inequality in different regions of the world. Together, the empirical evidence in the report becomes the backbone of a policy discussion that could play a key role in a human-centred recovery from the different ongoing crises.


DOWNLOAD HERE

ETUI advertisement

Social policy in the European Union: state of play 2022

Since 2000, the annual Bilan social volume has been analysing the state of play of social policy in the European Union during the preceding year, the better to forecast developments in the new one. Co-produced by the European Social Observatory (OSE) and the European Trade Union Institute (ETUI), the new edition is no exception. In the context of multiple crises, the authors find that social policies gained in ambition in 2022. At the same time, the new EU economic framework, expected for 2023, should be made compatible with achieving the EU’s social and ‘green’ objectives. Finally, they raise the question whether the EU Social Imbalances Procedure and Open Strategic Autonomy paradigm could provide windows of opportunity to sustain the EU’s social ambition in the long run.


DOWNLOAD HERE

Eurofound advertisement

Eurofound webinar: Making telework work for everyone

Since 2020 more European workers and managers have enjoyed greater flexibility and autonomy in work and are reporting their preference for hybrid working. Also driven by technological developments and structural changes in employment, organisations are now integrating telework more permanently into their workplace.

To reflect on these shifts, on 6 December Eurofound researchers Oscar Vargas and John Hurley explored the challenges and opportunities of the surge in telework, as well as the overall growth of telework and teleworkable jobs in the EU and what this means for workers, managers, companies and policymakers.


WATCH THE WEBINAR HERE

About Social Europe

Our Mission

Article Submission

Membership

Advertisements

Legal Disclosure

Privacy Policy

Copyright

Social Europe ISSN 2628-7641

Social Europe Archives

Search Social Europe

Themes Archive

Politics Archive

Economy Archive

Society Archive

Ecology Archive

Follow us

RSS Feed

Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter

Follow us on LinkedIn

Follow us on YouTube