Social Europe

politics, economy and employment & labour

  • Themes
    • Global cities
    • Strategic autonomy
    • War in Ukraine
    • European digital sphere
    • Recovery and resilience
  • Publications
    • Books
    • Dossiers
    • Occasional Papers
    • Research Essays
    • Brexit Paper Series
  • Podcast
  • Videos
  • Newsletter
  • Membership

The Bumpy Road Ahead Will Most Likely Lead To Scottish Independence

John Kay 29th April 2015

John Kay

John Kay

David Cameron anticipated that a referendum on independence for Scotland would produce a decisive No vote, damaging the Scottish National Party and burying the issue for a generation. And opinion polls suggested the odds favoured the gamble. But the UK prime minister’s judgment was mistaken, and the outcome of last September’s vote is likely to change permanently the face of British politics.

The No campaign emphasised the disadvantages of an independent Scotland rather than the advantages of a united Britain. If Scotland’s potential oil revenues had collapsed before the referendum rather than after, that argument might have been more compelling. In the event, the bullying of the later stages of the No campaign strengthened the resolve of those who wanted Yes.

To stabilise a rocky marriage, it is wiser to woo your partner with promises of shared happiness than to threaten the dire consequences of di­vorce. While the latter tactic may work for a bit, it is not a basis for a lasting relationship. Scotland is a case in point. The surge in SNP support after the referendum might have fallen back if the UK general election had been more than eight months away. As it is, every poll suggests that the SNP will win most of Scotland’s (largely Labour-held) Westminster seats in the May 7 vote.

The electoral arithmetic suggests that the opposition Labour party cannot obtain an overall majority without SNP support but might obtain one with. While a formal coalition is all but impossible, an understanding is feasible; the leftist MPs of the SNP will never vote to keep the Conservative Mr Cameron in power. So potential Labour voters in Scotland are offered the chance to elect a Labour government for the UK that is obliged to give special attention to Scotland. What is there for them not to like about that outcome?

Scottish Independence

The dynamics unfolding after the 7 May elections in the UK might lead to Scottish independence according to John Kay.

Ed Miliband, Labour leader, says today that he would not rely on the SNP to govern the country. But on May 8 he may face a choice between becoming prime minister with their backing or rejecting their support and losing the Labour leadership. If he then opted to enter Downing Street with SNP support, he would probably ensure the marginalisation of the Labour party in Scotland, not just in this election but forever. Why would Labour do better in Scotland in 2020 than in 2015?

Perhaps a few months in office would dispel the widespread belief that Mr Miliband is not a credible prime minister, and Labour could capture sufficient Conservative seats in a swiftly called second election to gain an overall majority. But even that faint hope does not defuse the UK’s Scottish problem.

The UK government’s policy document on devolution after the referendum, ludicrously subtitled ‘An Enduring Settlement‘, is full of unanswered questions. The hodgepodge financing deal known as the Barnett formula has no objective justification. And while the principle of ‘English votes for English laws’, recognised as a consequence of the referendum, has irresistible logic, the abstruse Barnett arithmetic ensures that every UK fiscal measure has implications for Scottish finances.

It is — just — possible to visualise a UK in which the SNP is one of several power brokers in a more fragmented party system, perhaps enjoying a relationship with Labour similar to that the Bavarian Christian Social Union has long held with Chancellor Angela Merkel’s Christian Democratic Union. But such an outcome requires imagination and co-operation beyond the capacity of most of the politicians who fill our screens. The more likely outcome for UK politics, whether Mr Cameron or Mr Miliband becomes prime minister, is progress down a bumpy road whose destination is Scottish independence. Such an outcome might by that time evoke cries of relief all round.

This column was first published in the Financial Times today and on John Kay’s blog.

John Kay

John Kay is Visiting Professor of Economics at the London School of Economics and a regular columnist for the Financial Times.

You are here: Home / Politics / The Bumpy Road Ahead Will Most Likely Lead To Scottish Independence

Most Popular Posts

Russia,information war Russia is winning the information warAiste Merfeldaite
Nanterre,police Nanterre and the suburbs: the lid comes offJoseph Downing
Russia,nuclear Russia’s dangerous nuclear consensusAna Palacio
Belarus,Lithuania A tale of two countries: Belarus and LithuaniaThorvaldur Gylfason and Eduard Hochreiter
retirement,Finland,ageing,pension,reform Late retirement: possible for many, not for allKati Kuitto

Most Recent Posts

Nagorno-Karabakh,European Union,EU,Azerbaijan,Armenia Azerbaijan exploits vacuum on Nagorno-KarabakhGeorge Meneshian
Abuse,work,workplace,violence Abuse at work: who bears the brunt?Agnès Parent-Thirion and Viginta Ivaskaite-Tamosiune
Ukraine,fatigue Ukraine’s cause: momentum is diminishingStefan Wolff and Tetyana Malyarenko
Vienna,social housing Vienna social-housing model: celebrated but misusedGabu Heindl
social democracy,nation-state Social democracy versus the nativist rightJan Zielonka

Other Social Europe Publications

strategic autonomy Strategic autonomy
Bildschirmfoto 2023 05 08 um 21.36.25 scaled 1 RE No. 13: Failed Market Approaches to Long-Term Care
front cover Towards a social-democratic century?
Cover e1655225066994 National recovery and resilience plans
Untitled design The transatlantic relationship

Eurofound advertisement

Eurofound Talks: does Europe have the skills it needs for a changing economy?

In this episode of the Eurofound Talks podcast, Mary McCaughey speaks with Eurofound’s research manager, Tina Weber, its senior research manager, Gijs van Houten, and Giovanni Russo, senior expert at CEDEFOP (The European Centre for the Development of Vocational Training), about Europe’s skills challenges and what can be done to help workers and businesses adapt to future skills demands.

Listen where you get your podcasts, or for free, by clicking on the link below


LISTEN HERE

Foundation for European Progressive Studies Advertisement

The summer issue of the Progressive Post magazine by FEPS is out!

The Special Coverage of this new edition is dedicated to the importance of biodiversity, not only as a good in itself but also for the very existence of humankind. We need a paradigm change in the mostly utilitarian relation humans have with nature.

In this issue, we also look at the hazards of unregulated artificial intelligence, explore the shortcomings of the EU's approach to migration and asylum management, and analyse the social downside of the EU's current ethnically-focused Roma policy.


DOWNLOAD HERE

Hans Böckler Stiftung Advertisement

WSI European Collective Bargaining Report 2022 / 2023

With real wages falling by 4 per cent in 2022, workers in the European Union suffered an unprecedented loss in purchasing power. The reason for this was the rapid increase in consumer prices, behind which nominal wage growth fell significantly. Meanwhile, inflation is no longer driven by energy import prices, but by domestic factors. The increased profit margins of companies are a major reason for persistent inflation. In this difficult environment, trade unions are faced with the challenge of securing real wages—and companies have the responsibility of making their contribution to returning to the path of political stability by reducing excess profits.


DOWNLOAD HERE

ETUI advertisement

The future of remote work

The 12 chapters collected in this volume provide a multidisciplinary perspective on the impact and the future trajectories of remote work, from the nexus between the location from where work is performed and how it is performed to how remote locations may affect the way work is managed and organised, as well as the applicability of existing legislation. Additional questions concern remote work’s environmental and social impact and the rapidly changing nature of the relationship between work and life.


AVAILABLE HERE

About Social Europe

Our Mission

Article Submission

Membership

Advertisements

Legal Disclosure

Privacy Policy

Copyright

Social Europe ISSN 2628-7641

Social Europe Archives

Search Social Europe

Themes Archive

Politics Archive

Economy Archive

Society Archive

Ecology Archive

Follow us

RSS Feed

Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter

Follow us on LinkedIn

Follow us on YouTube