Social Europe

politics, economy and employment & labour

  • Projects
    • Corporate Taxation in a Globalised Era
    • US Election 2020
    • The Transformation of Work
    • The Coronavirus Crisis and the Welfare State
    • Just Transition
    • Artificial intelligence, work and society
    • What is inequality?
    • Europe 2025
    • The Crisis Of Globalisation
  • Audiovisual
    • Audio Podcast
    • Video Podcasts
    • Social Europe Talk Videos
  • Publications
    • Books
    • Dossiers
    • Occasional Papers
    • Research Essays
    • Brexit Paper Series
  • Shop
  • Membership
  • Ads
  • Newsletter

An end to wage-dumping in the German meat industry?

by Şerife Erol and Thorsten Schulten on 26th January 2021 @ThorstenSchult6

Share on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on LinkedIn

The German meat industry is being pushed off its low road of migrant-labour exploitation towards regulation and potential collective agreement.

wage-dumping,German meat industry,migrant-labour exploitation
Şerife Erol

For a long time, the meat industry in Germany has been heavily criticised for wage-dumping by its European neighbours, based largely on exploitation of migrant workers from eastern Europe. Numerous outbreaks of Covid-19 in German slaughterhouses once more focused public attention on the precarious conditions of these workers. Now Germany has adopted a new legal framework, including a ban on contract and temporary agency work, creating an opportunity for a more fundamental renewal of labour relations in the sector.

wage-dumping,German meat industry,migrant-labour exploitation
Thorsten Schulten

As a result of a business model based on low-cost production, over the past two decades the German meat industry was highly successful in expanding its international market shares. Amid this transformation from a domestic to a largely export-oriented sector, Germany also became highly attractive as a location for slaughter and meat production.

Especially stark

Labour costs in the industry have been significantly lower than in other major European meat-producing countries, such as France, Belgium, the Netherlands or Denmark (see bar chart). The contrast with Denmark—where annual labour costs per employee at €69,000 are more than double the German level—is especially stark. Labour costs in Belgium and the Netherlands are also more than 65 per cent above those in Germany, with France 50 per cent higher.

Annual labour costs in the meat sector per full-time equivalent employee (€000s, 2018)

Source: Eurostat (2020), Annual Enterprise Statistics, authors’ compilation; *2017 data

The low-cost sectoral model in Germany goes hand-in-hand with specific labour relations. Organisation is rather weak and with low union density there are no industry-level collective agreements to set sector-wide employment standards. Most meat companies are not covered by any collective agreements and are bound only by legal minimum standards, such as the statutory minimum wage.

Moreover, almost all the firms have made extensive use of contract workers (Werkvertragsarbeiter), hired by specialist service companies which often recruit directly in eastern Europe. Although no official figures are available, the evidence indicates that this applies to up to 90 per cent of workers employed in slaughterhouses and meat packaging. A two-tier employment model surrounds a small core of directly hired workers with the bulk of contract workers, hired by the subcontractors under much less favourable conditions.

Join our growing community newsletter!

"Social Europe publishes thought-provoking articles on the big political and economic issues of our time analysed from a European viewpoint. Indispensable reading!"

Polly Toynbee

Columnist for The Guardian

Thank you very much for your interest! Now please check your email to confirm your subscription.

There was an error submitting your subscription. Please try again.

Powered by ConvertKit

Fundamental breaches

Indeed, there is considerable evidence that employment practices in the German meat industry continue to breach fundamental legal requirements. A December 2019 report from the labour inspection of North Rhine-Westphalia, encapsulating the results of visits to 30 slaughterhouses (with 17,000 workers hired by 90 service companies), found fully 9,000 violations of the law. Serious issues were identified in 85 per cent of plants inspected.

Most infringements involved working time, such as excessive working hours of more than 16 hours a day and non-compliance with mandatory rest periods. A lot of unpaid overtime undermined the formally paid statutory minimum wage. The inspections also revealed a lack of occupational health-and-safety facilities, technical safety shortcomings and poor workplace-safety organisation. Finally, accommodation for the migrant workers was quite unsatisfactory and insecure, often rented to them by the subcontracting companies at unreasonable rates.

The past decade has seen several initiatives to improve working conditions in the German industry, ranging from the temporary setting of a sectoral minimum wage to a voluntary commitment by employers to improve conditions and finally, in 2017, legislation targeted at employee rights in the industry. None however brought about any meaningful improvement.

New legal framework

When several meat firms were affected by significant Covid-19 outbreaks last spring, in the public debate a direct link was made to the associated working and housing conditions. In reaction, the federal government immediately announced a new legal framework to promote more fundamental changes in the sector. The Occupational Safety and Health Inspection Act (Arbeitsschutzkontrollgesetz) was finally adopted in December 2020. It encompasses a comprehensive set of provisions, with many new regulations requiring amendments to existing legislation.


We need your help! Please join our mission to improve public policy debates.


As you may know, Social Europe is an independent publisher. We aren't backed by a large publishing house or big advertising partners. For the longevity of Social Europe we depend on our loyal readers - we depend on you. You can support us by becoming a Social Europe member for less than 5 Euro per month.

Thank you very much for your support!

Become a Social Europe Member

The most significant, in force already since January 1st and valid for all meat companies with 50 or more employees, is a ban on contract work in the core areas of production, such as slaughtering, cutting and boning—only regularly employed workers of the principal employer will be allowed to engage in these areas. The government deems this necessary to end the lack of transparency associated with the coexistence of different employment forms in one workplace and to establish clear lines of responsibility for working conditions.

Moreover, there will be a ban on temporary agency work in these sectors from April 1st, to prevent companies simply converting contract work to that alternative. During a three-year transition, firms will be able to use agency workers on a limited basis—but only if their conditions are determined by a collective agreement. The government is thus pressing the companies to start collective bargaining with the trade unions.

There are also provisions for the improvement and enforcement of working conditions. Among others, meat-producing firms must record electronically employees’ hours of work, to monitor compliance with minimum-wage legislation. Inspection will also be significantly stepped up, with a minimum inspection ratio of 5 per cent of workplaces per annum.

Binding standards

The new legal framework is an important precondition of more fundamental improvement in working conditions. The ban on contract and temporary agency work and the overcoming of a two-tier workforce in the meat factories will also make it easier for trade unions to regain organisational strength at the workplace and to put pressure on the companies for better labour regulation.

On its own, however, the framework will not be sufficient to ensure decent conditions across the sector, as the companies are only obliged to provide the legal minimum requirements, such as the statutory minimum wage. A further vital step would be resumption of industry-level collective bargaining, to determine binding standards throughout the sector.

Given the intense competition in the industry, establishing decent working conditions requires a floor of industry-wide minimum standards, to prevent individual firms gaining a competitive advantage simply through low-cost production. To ensure better working and living conditions for the migrant workers, industry-level collective bargaining would have to encompass not only such minimum provisions but also—as in other industries—more comprehensive stipulations to ensure decent conditions for all employees, covering pay, working time, holidays and so on.

Such an agreement would offer a binding framework for competition in the industry and contribute to ending destructive price competition on the backs of the workforce. It would also represent an important step towards a much-needed change in the sector’s dominant business model and could indeed lead to an end to wage-dumping in the German meat industry.

Share on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on LinkedIn
Home ・ Economy ・ An end to wage-dumping in the German meat industry?

Filed Under: Economy

About Şerife Erol and Thorsten Schulten

Serife Erol is a research associate at the Institute of Economic and Social Research (WSI) at the Hans Böckler Stiftung and PhD candidate at the Ruhr-University Bochum. For her master's thesis she conducted qualitative research on working conditions and labour relations in the German meat sector. Thorsten Schulten is head of the collective-agreements archive of the WSI and an honorary professor at the University of Tübingen.

Partner Ads

Most Popular Posts

Thomas Piketty,capital Capital and ideology: interview with Thomas Piketty Thomas Piketty
sovereignty Brexit and the misunderstanding of sovereignty Peter Verovšek
China,cold war The first global event in the history of humankind Branko Milanovic
centre-left, Democratic Party The Biden victory and the future of the centre-left EJ Dionne Jr
Covid 19 vaccine Designing vaccines for people, not profits Mariana Mazzucato, Henry Lishi Li and Els Torreele

Most Recent Posts

SDR,special drawing rights Europe could make good use of a new SDR allocation Jayati Ghosh
socio-ecological contract The four ‘I’s of a new socio-ecological contract Philippe Pochet
supply chain,Germany,human rights Germany’s proposed supply-chain law—a glass half-empty Johanna Kusch and Claudia Saller
Myanmar,due diligence Human-rights due diligence and Myanmar Frank Hoffer
Uber,drivers,gig UK gig drivers recognised as workers—what next? Jill Toh

Other Social Europe Publications

RE No. 12: Why No Economic Democracy in Sweden?
US election 2020
Corporate taxation in a globalised era
The transformation of work
The coronavirus crisis and the welfare state

Eurofound advertisement

Industrial relations: developments 2015-2019

Eurofound has monitored and analysed developments in industrial relations systems at EU level and in EU member states for over 40 years. This new flagship report provides an overview of developments in industrial relations and social dialogue in the years immediately prior to the Covid-19 outbreak. Findings are placed in the context of the key developments in EU policy affecting employment, working conditions and social policy, and linked to the work done by social partners—as well as public authorities—at European and national levels.


CLICK FOR MORE INFO

Foundation for European Progressive Studies Advertisement

FEPS Progressive Yearbook

Twenty-twenty has been an extraordinary year. The Covid-19 pandemic and the multidimensional crisis that it triggered have boosted existing trends and put forward new challenges. But they have also created unexpected opportunities to set a new course of action for the European Union and—hopefully—make a remarkable leap forward in European integration.

The second edition of the Progressive Yearbook, the yearly publication of the Foundation for European Progressive studies, revolves around the exceptional events of 2020 and looks at the social, economic and political impact they will have in 2021. It is a unique publication, which aims to be an instrument for the progressive family to reflect on the recent past and look ahead to our next future.


CLICK HERE

Social Europe Publishing book

With a pandemic raging, for those countries most affected by Brexit the end of the transition could not come at a worse time. Yet, might the UK's withdrawal be a blessing in disguise? With its biggest veto player gone, might the European Pillar of Social Rights take centre stage? This book brings together leading experts in European politics and policy to examine social citizenship rights across the European continent in the wake of Brexit. Will member states see an enhanced social Europe or a race to the bottom?

'This book correctly emphasises the need to place the future of social rights in Europe front and centre in the post-Brexit debate, to move on from the economistic bias that has obscured our vision of a progressive social Europe.' Michael D Higgins, president of Ireland


MORE INFO

Hans Böckler Stiftung Advertisement

Renewing labour relations in the German meat industry: an end to 'organised irresponsibility'?

Over the course of 2020, repeated outbreaks of Covid-19 in a number of large German meat-processing plants led to renewed public concern about the longstanding labour abuses in this industry. New legislation providing for enhanced inspection on health and safety, together with a ban on contract work and limitations on the use of temporary agency employees, holds out the prospect of a profound change in employment practices and labour relations in the meat industry. Changes in the law are not sufficient, on their own, to ensure decent working conditions, however. There is also a need to re-establish the previously high level of collective-bargaining coverage in the industry, underpinned by an industry-wide collective agreement extended by law to cover the entire sector.


FREE DOWNLOAD

ETUI advertisement

ETUI/ETUC (online) conference Towards a new socio-ecological contract 3-5 February 2021

The need to effectively tackle global warming puts under pressure the existing industrial relations models in Europe. A viable world of labour requires a new sustainability paradigm: economic, social and environmental.

The required paradigm shift implies large-scale economic and societal change and serious deliberation. All workers need to be actively involved and nobody should be left behind. Massive societal coalitions will have to be built for a shared vision to emerge and for a just transition, with fairly distributed costs, to be supported. But this is also an opportunity to redefine our societal goals and how they relate to the current focus on (green) growth.


REPLAY ALL SESSIONS

To access the videos, click on the chosen day then click on the ‘video’ button of your chosen session (plenary or panel). It will bring you immediately to the corresponding video. To access the available presentations, click on the chosen day then click on the ‘information’ button. Check the links to the available presentations.

About Social Europe

Our Mission

Article Submission

Legal Disclosure

Privacy Policy

Copyright

Social Europe ISSN 2628-7641

Find Social Europe Content

Search Social Europe

Project Archive

Politics Archive

Economy Archive

Society Archive

Ecology Archive

.EU Web Awards